Rana Sarkar shunted aside; Liberals get Mandarin-speaking candidate
Toronto’s suburbs are becoming a Mandarin-speaking powerhouse for the federal Liberal Party.
Four ridings around in Toronto have Chinese-Canadians candidates, and in sharp contrast to the Conservatives’ top-down ethnic strategy of wooing voters through messaging that appeals to a specific minority, the Mandarin community is fielding its own candidates. In Don Valley North’s nomination contest, scientist Geng Tan upset presumed front-runner Rana Sarkar, a veteran party member and friend of Gerald Butts, Leader Justin Trudeau’s top adviser. Mr. Geng accomplished this by appealing almost solely to a monolithic base of Mandarin-speakers in Mandarin only.
Arnold Chan, elected in Scarborough-Agincourt last month, is Toronto’s first Liberal Chinese MP. Would this alienate other minorities?
A pivotal figure in this wider political development is Michael Chan, an influential Ontario cabinet minister and fundraiser who stepped outside his daily sphere during June’s provincial election to bolster his community’s voice in the federal party. Mr. Chan’s involvement, along with the number of Chinese-Canadian candidates, indicates the growing demographic power of the Mandarin vote, whose participation has long been seen as dormant.
”Mr. Geng said his campaign embraced a wide group of ethnicities. He pointed to the endorsement of former MPP David Caplan, who is Jewish. A chemist who works at Ontario Power Generation, Mr. Geng said he deals with every constituency in the riding and is simply bringing a new group into the political fold.
Is this a detrimental version of identity politics? “What they have done is un-Canadian,” said Yiannis Stamatakos, a Sarkar supporter who said he has worked on 50 nomination campaigns. While it’s not uncommon for a political party to nominate say, a Jew, Sikh or Arab in a riding where that group has big numbers, he added, usually those minorities round up a list whose membership consists of two-thirds or three-quarters of his or her own background, not 100 per cent.
According to Sarkar supporters, Geng voters wore name tags that were in Mandarin and English, the latter making it easier for organizers to identify the members if they didn’t speak English.
