Conservative News & Right Wing News | Gun Laws & Rights News Site

EU wins political-deal clause that could suspend trade deal

eu

EU wins political-deal clause that could suspend trade deal

A clause that could lead to an eventual suspension of the Canada-European Union free trade deal over human rights issues has found its way into a recently announced political agreement between the two sides—despite Canada’s initial objection, Embassy has learned.
Several European Union officials in Brussels, the EU nerve centre, have confirmed the clause is included in the so-called Strategic Partnership Agreement, a deal that outlines an overarching framework for Canada-EU co-operation on various global issues, including security, energy, research and innovation as well as the Arctic.

Foreign Minister John Baird celebrated the end of negotiations towards the political deal during EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs Catherine Ashton’s visit to Ottawa on Sept. 8. The two sides had been negotiating the SPA since 2011 at the EU’s request, largely in parallel to, but separate from, the more high-profile trade deal, called the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement, or CETA.

Embassy reported in May 2013 about Canadian concerns over proposed text in the SPA that would link trade to human rights protection and nuclear non-proliferation, and which would allow the EU to suspend CETA if it found Canada wasn’t living up to human rights or non-proliferation standards. Canada could do the same to the EU.

Liberal Senator Joan Fraser mused in the Senate in April 2013 that the Europeans could use the clause to “attack Canada on grounds from the oil sands to the seal hunt to I know not what.” An EU official in June 2013 said the Canadian concern was that the EU would single out Canada for First Nations issues or the seal hunt, but in fact it would take much more than that to suspend the deal.

The EU has been using this model in its political framework agreements with countries less developed than the 28 member states as a way to condition trade and development assistance to a country’s performance in maintaining international human rights and non-proliferation commitments.

The EU has argued this formula must be maintained with Canada as well in order to be consistent and to avoid setting a precedent that would jeopardize talks with other countries in the future.

It insisted both publicly and behind the scenes on this approach, aiming to reassure Canadians about the unlikelihood of the clause ever being invoked.

But Canada’s opposition continued. A lack of compromise on the matter helped put the deal’s conclusion nearly two years behind schedule. The goal was to wrap the agreement up in 2012, according to comments in front of the House foreign affairs committee by Canada’s SPA chief negotiator at the time, Alexandra Bugailiskis, in February 2012. By May 2013, the major sticking point hovered around this controversial clause.

Although the EU and Canada cheered the deal’s conclusion in September, both parties remained mum on how they managed to resolve this conflict.

The text of the agreement has not been released yet, unlike that of its sister deal, which was officially published on Sept. 26. The political and trade deals must go through a process of legal revisions, translation and approval in the Canadian and European parliaments.

Nevertheless, officials confirmed the EU managed to convince Canada to keep the two issues linked.

“We were patient and persistent and came up with this rather convoluted process, which we feel is a common approach in its spirit and its effect,” an EU official said, speaking on condition of anonymity.

“But the main point is that, going forward, the idea of linking human rights and non-proliferation to actions on these in both SPA and CETA is possible as a decision of the EU and that’s essentially what we need.”

The technicalities

The SPA outlines a series of measures that could be taken by either side in case of violations of human rights or nuclear non-proliferation commitments. The issue could be dealt with institutionally, through dialogue or, if no solution is found, the SPA could also be suspended, the EU official explained.

In the event that the SPA is suspended, either side could also go further if the situation requires it, including by terminating the trade deal. But the CETA could only be suspended under its own rules, enshrined within the trade agreement, the official added.

The CETA text Canada and the EU released on Sept. 26 includes a paragraph highlighting “the importance of international security, democracy, human rights and the rule of law for the development of international trade and economic cooperation.” Another paragraph refers to weapons of mass destruction as a major threat to international security.

The text includes a joint declaration in which both sides “confirm their understanding that measures that are related to the maintenance of international peace and security include the protection of human rights.”

But these are just introductory paragraphs meant to connect the SPA to the CETA. The operative paragraphs are only within SPA, the EU official explained. In other words, the suspensive clause is only in the SPA and can be technically used to suspend both agreements.

Canadian government officials confirmed that “in the exceptional circumstance of a serious and substantial violation of human rights or non-proliferation by either party, a series of measures could be taken from high-level dialogue up to the suspension of the SPA.”

When asked specifically about the trade link, Francois Lasalle, spokesperson at the Department of Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development, pointed out—like the EU official—that the trade deal has its own termination mechanism.

“This is a standard termination clause that exists irrespective of the SPA, and any action to terminate the Canada-EU trade agreement would have to be taken under that agreement,” Lasalle wrote in an email.

He would not directly comment on whether measures in the SPA could also trigger the termination of CETA, albeit under its own rules.

‘Not about’ Canada

The EU official said the link with trade issues within the political deal “had absolutely nothing to do with Canada.”

“We told them many times ‘It’s not about you,’” the EU official said. “We need this for the deals we are going to make with other countries, where we are trying to hold up the fact that human rights and non-proliferation standards are things that we expect must be met before we can continue a commercial relationship.”

Canadians have always regarded the SPA as an “unnecessary complication of the CETA negotiations,” said Achim Hurrelmann, director at Carleton University’s Institute of European, Russian and Eurasian Studies. But in the end “both sides agreed to see the SPA as a formality, something that had to be concluded to keep in line with the EU’s standard template for international trade deals of this kind,” he added.

“Canada’s objections against including human rights and non-proliferation clauses in the SPA were primarily a matter of national pride,” Mr. Hurrelmann said. “If these clauses are now in the agreement…this suggests that the Canadians accepted in the end that they should not take these provisions all that personal. The objective of preventing further delays to CETA was clearly more important to them.”

EU officials had wanted the SPA and trade deal as a package.

http://www.embassynews.ca/news/2014/10/01/eu-wins-political-deal-clause-that-could-suspend-trade-deal/46133

Exit mobile version