As world leaders, negotiators, and activists gathered in Antalya, Turkey, for COP31 — the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference, running from November 9 to 20 — the heavy presence of international nongovernmental organizations (INGOs) was once again on full display.
Outsized Influence
These groups shape agendas, organize events, pressure delegations, and push implementation targets on electrification, methane, and “climate-resilient cities.” Their outsized role is no accident. It is the continuation of a long institutional trajectory whose modern milestone was the 1992 United Nations Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro.
In Constructing World Culture, scholars John Boli and George M. Thomas said, “For example, at the United Nations Earth Summit in Rio in 1992, nongovernmental organizations were granted official accreditation, which gave them access to national delegations as well as the right to propose draft treaties and influence negotiations.” That formal recognition transformed INGOs from outside pressure groups into accepted participants in the writing of global rules. What began in Rio as accreditation has matured into routine, institutionalized acceptance of legislation being written not by the people’s representatives, but by these unelected organizations.
Boli and Thomas tracked the growth and proliferation of these organizations, and they show how INGOs — environmental, human-rights, technical, and development bodies — have helped construct a comprehensive “world polity.” Through the creation and diffusion of global cultural principles, INGOs translate abstract aspirations into concrete institutions, policies, and practices that constrain and reshape states themselves.
Redefining Culture
Ever wonder why “woke culture” is suddenly being foisted upon a shocked and unsuspecting audience interested in nothing more than athletics? The Olympics Committee is an international NGO. Ever wonder why your favorite sporting event suddenly has an LGBT “Pride Awareness” night? It’s because most sports are controlled by international NGOs such as the International Association Football Federation (FIFA), International Federation of American Football (IFAF), International Basketball Federation (FIBA), and so forth.
This organizational model for international NGOs emerged as a successor to formal empire. In The Influence of the Carnegie, Ford, and Rockefeller Foundations on American Foreign Policy, Edward H. Berman observes, “The conceptualization of these foundation educational ventures coincided with the demise of the colonial empires of Britain, France and the Netherlands after 1945.” As European colonial administrations collapsed, foundations and the INGOs they supported stepped into the vacuum, cultivating elites and disseminating new norms. Berman adds the deeper cultural logic: “Those who control the production and dissemination of culture and ideas influence, to a great degree, the way in which people view the world and the commonplace categories into which they organize their knowledge and by which they conduct their lives.”
Shadow Legislators
The result is a system in which international NGOs function as shadow legislators for an emerging world polity. Often the people’s elected representatives are not the primary authors of the frameworks that later bind them, the INGOs are. Global goals are drafted in transnational forums, refined by accredited NGOs, and then cascaded downward.
That cascade is visible today inside the United States. States and localities are quietly incorporating UN “Sustainable Development” and Agenda 2030 schemes into regional planning, comprehensive land-use plans, and zoning ordinances. Under the language of environmental protection and equity, these measures frequently restrict property rights and local control — precisely the pattern of voluntary local implementation of globalist goals that Boli, Thomas, and Berman anticipate.
From Rio’s accreditation breakthrough to the active role of INGOs at COP31 in Turkey, and from foundation-sponsored cultural projects after 1945 to the quiet adoption of Agenda 2030 language in American city halls, the same institutional logic is at work: unelected transnational organizations constructing the categories, drafting the norms, and shaping the rules under which formerly sovereign peoples increasingly live.
This article is part of The New American’s weekly online newsletter Insider Report, which is emailed to TNA subscribers each week. Click here to subscribe to The New American to receive the Insider Report and access exclusive content.
