EU members at odds over trade deal with Canada

eu

 

EU members at odds over trade deal with Canada

The controversial investment protection chapter of the Canada-European Union trade deal should not be reopened, Italy’s vice minister of trade said on Sept. 3, putting his comments at odds with those of other EU countries—and raising further questions about the approval process of the much-awaited deal.

“We [member states] gave the [European] Commission the mandate to negotiate the investor-state dispute settlement agreement. Now that negotiations are finished, it is difficult to say we changed [our mind] and let’s re-discuss,” Carlo Calenda, Italy’s vice-minister of trade, told members of the European Parliament during a meeting of the parliament’s international trade committee. “If we move in this way, we will have to open up all the chapters and waste a lot of time.”

Italy is currently presiding over the Council of the European Union, the body where national ministers from each of the 28 member countries meet to adopt laws and co-ordinate policies.

Mr. Calenda was addressing what has now become a point of debate in various European countries on the Canada-EU Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement, but much less so in Canada.

The investor-state dispute settlement mechanism, or ISDS,is a provision that lets corporations seek compensation from states if government policies hurt their business interests. Canada asked for the inclusion of ISDS in CETA at the end of 2010, wishing to preserve a model it was using under NAFTA.

“CETA is concluded…we can approve it or not, but not reopen the chapters,” he said.

But in an interview with Embassy on Aug. 18, Germany’s ambassador to Canada, Werner Wnendt, openly questioned the need for investment protection regulations in CETA, pointing instead to existing bilateral investment agreements that Germany has with many countries.

Similar arguments whirl around the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership that the EU is negotiating with the United States, with France also opposing ISDS in that deal with the US. In fact, Mr. Calenda admitted the ISDS question in CETA is very much related to the US negotiations.

Civil society groups worry that ISDS provisions limit a government’s ability to regulate to protect public health or the environment.

‘State of the art’ investment chapter: EU negotiator

Mauro Petriccione, the EU’s CETA chief negotiator, also speaking at the international trade committee meeting on Sept. 3, repeatedly described the investment protection part of the deal as “state of the art.”

“This is the state of the art and I mean it literally,” he told MEPs. “This is where we are today based on a specific mandate, based on a debate in the parliament and a debate with civil society.”

“The debate isn’t finished,” he added. “I cannot promise you that this text answers concerns that are still being debated or which may arise in the future.”

“We are not saying it is a done deal. You will decide if it’s a done deal,” he told MEPs. Furthermore, if the European Council decides to reopen some chapters, this will be a political decision that the European Commission will have to comply with, he said. The European Council represents the heads of state or government of all member states, not to be confused with the Council of the European Union.

“But I am not sure Canada will agree to re-negotiate,” Mr. Petriccione said. “So we have to think about the consequences.”

Officials from the European Commission, the EU’s executive body tasked with negotiating CETA on behalf of member states, previously pointed out that ISDS was never contentious until opposition to the US-EU deal also grew, which could contain a similar chapter to the Canadian deal.

Canada announced the official end of CETA negotiations in August. Prime Minister Stephen Harper and European Commission President José Manuel Barroso are set to meet for a joint Canada-EU summit in Ottawa on Sept. 25. They are expected to initial the agreement at the meeting, almost a year after the two met in Brussels to announce that an agreement “in principle” had been reached.

Following this, the text will have to pass through legal scrubbing and translation, after which it will be passed on for approval in the European Council and European Parliament. The question is still open as to whether national parliaments in member states would have to ratify it as well.

Mr. Petriccione shied away from assigning any specific timeline for wrapping up the deal. He only said there are no expectations for CETA to come into force before the beginning of 2016. But even that might be too early, he said.

“As of today, I wouldn’t bet on it,” he said, clarifying his comments as personal, and not representing those of the European Commission.

http://www.embassynews.ca/news/2014/09/03/eu-members-at-odds-on-canada-eu-trade-deal/45989

Tags: