You Can’t Wear American Flag Shirts On Cinco De Mayo
This Appeals Court Just Agreed: You Can’t Wear American Flag Shirts On Cinco De Mayo
Freedom of speech — and common sense – took a heavy hit this week. The U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has agreed with a lower court, that students can be stopped from wearing American Flag T-shirts on Cinco de Mayo. Ironically, the decision came on September 17th… which is Constitution Day.
The events that lead to the court case happened back in 2010, when Live Oak High School officials in California told students they were not allowed to wear U.S.-themed shirts on May 5, because it might cause conflict and violence with Mexican-American students celebrating Cinco de Mayo.
At the time, students were told that they had to turn their American flag shirts inside out, or go home. Some students of Mexican heritage complained that the patriotic shirts were incendiary, and meant to be offensive. The school in question has had gang problems over the years, and tensions between Latinos and white students are often high.
Somewhat oddly, Cinco de Mayo is not celebrated as a major holiday in Mexico, but is usually more popular in the United States. The date is not Mexico’s Independence Day — that is actually in September — but rather marks the defeat of the French at the Battle of Pueblo.
Can schools or other organizations now ban anything they wish, if anybody complains that something is offensive? How can a patriotic American flag be seen as offensive within the actual United States of America? Those questions remain unanswered, however the court’s decision is troubling for freedom of expression and free speech.
