The Alarm Bell Is Clanging

We are all aware that democracy is not a modern invention.  It was characteristic of many city-states in the ancient world.  Athens, for instance, had a flourishing democracy in the 5th and 4th centuries B.C., until the independence of the city disappeared in the emerging age of empires.  Rome had a “mixed” constitution in which democracy was an important element until the republic vanished, to be replaced by monarchy in the first century B.C., the age of Caesar and Augustus.

We moderns didn’t create democracy.  However, beginning with the American Founding Fathers, we created and sustained democracy in large societies such as the USA and many European countries.  I say we have “sustained” it.  This is true up to the present moment.  But how long will it remain true?  The oldest of these large modern democracies is the United States, and our democracy dates back only to the generation following our anti-monarchical War of Independence, not quite 250 years.

An Athenian living in the age of Demosthenes (4th century B.C.) might have said, “We Athenians have sustained our democracy for more than a century now.  Hopefully it will last forever.”  Alas, it died at approximately the same moment that Demosthenes, the last great democrat, died (322 B.C.).

One of the tremendous weaknesses of ancient democracies — a weakness that we moderns, and we Americans especially, should pay great attention to — was their bad practice of politicizing their judicial systems.  Politician X wasn’t content to defeat his opponent at the polls.  No, he wanted to prosecute him, drive him into exile, impose ruinous fines on him, put him to death.

The most famous instance of this in Athens was the prosecution of Socrates.  Following its defeat by Sparta in the Peloponnesian War, Athens was briefly ruled by “Thirty Tyrants,” an oligarchical, anti-democratic clique.  But democrats soon rose up and overthrew the oligarchy, re-establishing the democracy.  A few years later, some ardent democrats prosecuted Socrates, seeking his death.

Socrates was not himself a politician.  He said that his “voice” or “sign” told him not to be a politician.  Nonetheless, he had many friends and acquaintances among politicians, including anti-democratic politicians.  And he was known to be a critic of democracy, which, by giving power to average men, gave power to men who (in his opinion) were intellectually and morally deficient.  Socrates also had a low opinion of oligarchs, who (in his opinion) were so stupid and wicked as to place great value on wealth.

But the prosecutors of Socrates figured that, since he was an anti-democrat, he must be pro-oligarch; there was no third possibility.  And so, with the help of a jury they could rely on, they did him in.